Chalcedon Report Current Issue
Economics, Justice, and Preaching

   
  In This Issue
  Back Issues
   
 
SUBSCRIPTIONS
Subscribe today to the original magazine on
the Christian world
and life view.

  Complimentary Issue
  Magazine Subscription
   
FREE ACCESS
  Free MP3s!
  Free Newsletter
  Rushdoony Podcast
  Chalcedon Podcast
  Homeschooling Blog
  Chalcedon Blog
•  Articles
•  New - Español
•  Chalcedon e-Store
   
UNDERWRITER ACCESS
  Become an Underwriter
  FFAOL Magazine
•  MP3 Audio
   
ADMINISTRATION
  Log In
  Log Out
  Manage Profile
•  Advertising Rates
•  Contact Us
•  Privacy Policy
•  Support Chalcedon
•  Who We Are
• 
   

Monday, January 02, 2006

Compassion Is Not a Substitute for Justice

In a recent post, "Don't Mess with John Lofton," we linked to an excellent interview with John Lofton of The American View and James Winkler of the UMC on C-SPAN. In this interview James Winkler refused to site any biblical or constitutional basis for wanting the federal government to provide cradle-to-grave security for the people. What he proposed over and over again was not only a social gospel, but a Socialist State. Here is a direct quote from Mr. Winkler: "I think what is moral and just is that we demand of those who have more, what they can provide" (emphasis added). He also said in response to Romans chapter 13 that "the government ought to address evil and I think when you have a situation where you have in a nation as wealthy as ours, so many poor, so many without health insurance, so many in need, that's an evil, that's a form of evil." The only problem with this is that neither Mr. Winkler nor the UMC is God. They do not determine what is good and evil, rather it is God and God alone via His Holy Word. The only basis Mr. Winkler gives for anything he espouses is "I think" or "I believe" or "the American people believe."

Shortly after listening to this interview, I listened to R.J. Rushdoony's lecture on the case laws given in Exodus 23:1-8. In this lecture, Rushdoony provides an excellent response to Mr. Winkler's socialism. You can listen to Rushdoony's lecture online here: http://www.chalcedon.edu/radio/Godsjustice.php.

This lecture is one of the many lectures found on the Exodus: Commentaries on the Pentateuch CD Set.